717-609-2845 info@carlislebakery.com

We Put the “Eat” in Treats!

There is Always a Reason

For a Tasty Treat!


A treat is anything that makes you feel good after eating it, something that helps melt the stress of the day away. At the bakery, we work non-stop to create treats that not only look appealing but taste delectable. From our cookies to cakes, tarts to breakfast pastries, and even our gluten free line, we offer a wide range of options for you. Stop by, and see why we put the “eats” in “Treats”!

  • Specialty Cakes
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes
  • Pastries
  • Coffee


At the Carlisle Bakery, we make all of our specialty cakes to order! We use fresh ingredients, including real butter, flour, milk, and eggs. A specialty cake does not have to be extravagant to be special. We offer a line of cakes simplistically, but elegantly, decorated to fit any occasion. Whether celebrating 50 years of marriage or 1 month of friendship, everything is always better with cake!

What is a cupcake?

Straight and to the point…a cupcake is a small cake. However, to us, it is so much more. We believe that cupcakes offer our guests a wider spectrum to release their creativity. From off the wall flavor combinations to off the wall decorations we can customize your cupcakes to fit your passion. Our decorating team always says that there is almost nothing we can’t do with cupcakes!

Got a cookie craving? Our cookie collection includes short bread, tea cookies, and our popular home-style cookies. Home-style cookie flavors are chocolate chip, sugar, snicker doodle, oatmeal raisin and peanut butter. And they’re cheaper by the dozen. Check them out and all our cookies on the online order menu.

Pastry is the most versatile word in a bakery’s arsenal. A pastry can be anything and everything when it comes to the world of sweets. However, a pastry does not always need to be sweet, some are actually savory. Whether you like them sweet or savory, filled, topped, or perfect they way they are, a pastry from the Carlisle Bakery is sure to please!